Cindy was sitting at her desk doing homework, already dressed for bed. She heard a knock at her door and took her time going to open in. She was more than a little confused when she saw Jaden standing in her doorway.
She tried to shut the door but he put his body in the way. He then grabbed her by the waist and pulled her into a hug. When she made noise he covered her mouth with his, all the while working his hands under her night shirt. He stopped at her breasts and began to rub his thumbs over her nipples. She moaned slightly but focused on breaking her face away so she could talk.
“What are you doing here?”
“I couldn’t wait.” He reached into his back pocket and produced a long plastic chopstick, the type used to bind hair and not to eat with.
It took Cindy a moment to realize what he planned to do with it. “You want to fuck my peehole with that?” she was shocked.
“You’re so clever,” he giggled.
“Wait, I’m still sore from yesterday. Why are you even here again so soon?”
“I told you, I couldn’t wait.” He crouched down and pulled the crotch of her pajama shorts aside, exposing her cunt. She gasped as he spread it in search of her urethra. She grabbed two tufts of his hair and tried to pull him away or back to his feet. He ignored her and managed to find his prize. When he pushed the tip of the chopstick into her urethra, she shrieked.
He stood up and covered her mouth with his hand. When she backed up, he followed her into the room and pressed her to the nearest wall. She was squirming as he had brought the chopstick up into her with his other hand when he stood up. Her eyes were crossed and tears were running down her cheeks.
“Are you okay?” he was concerned. He spoke in a low voice as if that would somehow offset how loud she had been.
She shook her head in response. He pulled the chopstick out slightly and she sighed with relief. He smiled at the expression on her face. He loved that he could control so many of her reactions. He pushed it back in a little, making her squeal and her eyes roll around in her head.
“Sorry,” he apologized half heartedly. “I just really wanted to see if this would fit in you the moment I saw it.”
Cindy just kept shaking her head, trying to pull away but being completely powerless against someone older and stronger than her. Finally, overwhelmed and unable to breath deeply enough with her mouth covered, she passed out standing up. Her full weight fell on Jaden and he worried the chopstick would go too deep in her urethra. He pulled it out and let her fall to the floor. Unconscious and unable to stop herself, she relieved her bladder on the floor of her room.
“Cindy, what’s all that screaming!” Jaden heard her mother calling up the stairs. He had been invited over for dinner and had slipped away while Kayla helped her mother prepare. It had been quite daring of him to try raping Cindy again while her mother was home. It was no wonder she was so shocked. He took a towel from Cindy’s closet and used it to soak up most of her urine, then shut the door behind him as he left.
—————————————————————————————————————————————————————-
It was weeks before Cindy saw Jaden again. She had been terrified when he showed up at her door even when her mother was at home, but her reluctance and eventually fainting seemed to deter him from doing too much to her. She had hoped never to see him again, but that conviction had wavered during his absence.
She was now accustomed to things being shoved into her urethra and spent a lot of time in the following weeks thinking about it. Every time she was in the bathroom or shower, she spread her cunt and looked at the tiny hole in the mirror. She had used the detectable shower head to spray water into it a few times and while it was uncomfortable, she could not get enough of it.
In the end, when she heard her mother was going out for the night and saw Kayla texting Jaden it was clear to come over that day, she found herself more excited than afraid. She ran straight to her room to put on an outfit she thought he would like; one with shorts that would give him easy access to her lower half. She did not find it odd at all she was preparing to get played with.
During the past month, Kayla’s and Jaden’s relationship had progressed past a simple fling, hence his invitation to have dinner with them. She had won him over easily by offering her body to him, but now she had noticed his interest waning and she was determined to win him back by proving to be a proper girlfriend he could rely on.
As such, that night she planned to cook for him, rather than just ordering pizza like usual. She was still in the kitchen in front of the stove when the doorbell rang. “Cindy, can you get that?” she shouted in the living room where her sister was watching TV.
Cindy bounded for the front door excitedly. She opened it and only hesitated for a second to make sure their guest was in fact Jaden before she leapt at him. She had to stand on the tips of her toes to reach his face but she managed to kiss him on the lips. He looked happy to see her until he saw into the kitchen where Kayla was. He managed to turn his head just in time to make it look like she was just kissing his cheek before Kayla saw them.
She marched up behind Cindy had yanked her off of Jaden by one of her pigtails. Jaden was startled and missed the chance to greet his girlfriend properly. When he noticed Kayla tapping her foot he apologized. “It’s fine, just don’t humor her too much,” she warned him. She did not think there could ever be anything between her boyfriend and her much younger sister, but she also did not want to be responsible for hurting Cindy’s feelings in case she gained expectations.
“Come watch TV with me.” Cindy dragged him into the house, almost causing him to drop the paper bag he was holding. He looked at Kayla for permission. She ignored him and went back to the kitchen to finish cooking.
It was only after Cindy had deposited him on the couch that he realized she was wearing a skirt for the first time he had ever seen her. He was mesmerized by the shape of her hips moving beneath it and almost didn’t notice her sliding her panties to the floor before leaping onto his lap. She moaned loudly, forcing him to cover her mouth. With his other hand he felt underneath her and found her crotch incredibly wet. He could not hide his smirk as he realized she’d been looking forward to his visit.
She gyrated her hips, trying to rub her crotch against the slowly growing bulge in his pants. He was so focused on keeping her mouth covered that he barely noticed he was getting hard until she tried to undo his zipper. He grabbed her by the wrist to stop her. The last thing he needed was for Kayla to walk out of the kitchen and catch them both with their crotches exposed.
Cindy looked disappointed but just kept moving her waist and rubbing against him. When he uncovered her mouth for a moment she started moaning again. Frowning, he grabbed the paper bag he had set on the coffee table and retrieved something from inside. She stopped moving at the sight of a large blue plastic phallus, at least as big as Jaden’s if not bigger. “What are you doing with that?” she muttered.
“I brought some toys this time,” he explained.
“You don’t think that will fit in my peehole, do you?” she was slightly terrified.
“You have other holes,” he reminded her.
She instinctively covered her butt. After a moment of thought, she opened her mouth, willingly offering it to him. It was the hole she thought would hurt the least and if he was determined to penetrate her, she wanted to at least decide where. He grinned as she seemed to be thinking the same thing he was. Without warning or lubrication, he shoved the tip of the dildo into her mouth, effectively stopping her moaning.
She tried to swallow but found it impossible. The dildo was too large and just stretched her jaw. Jaden held the back of her head with one hand and pressed the dildo with the other one, sliding it into her mouth and eventually the back of her throat. Her eyes were wide with concern. Saliva dripped out of the corners of her mouth as she could not close it.
Satisfied she was gagged and could no longer draw Kayla’s attention; he returned one of his hands to her crotch and began to fiddle with her pussy and clit. She winced and whimpered but was too busy trying not to choke to really get into the feeling of having her pussy touched. She had stopped all of her own attempts to feel his cock through his pants too.
Eventually, Jaden lost interest in just touching Cindy. He opened the bag again and produced a fist full of what looking like plastic eggs to her. He set them in the crevice of the couch and then picked one of them to press against her wet cunt. She squealed as it was forced past the opening. It was almost too big, but the rounded shape allowed her cunt to open and then close around it.
He repeated this 5 more times until she had all 6 inside her. When he looked at her face he found her eyes completely white and drool running down her chin. There was a remote in the bag that would make the eggs vibrate inside her. He was about to retrieve it when he heard a noise from the kitchen. Kayla had just taken a pot off the stove. “It’s ready, but hot,” she called when she saw him looking. “We can watch the end of whatever’s on before we eat.”
Jaden quickly grabbed the end of the dildo in Cindy’s mouth and twisted it, as if trying to unscrew it from her throat. She wretched and spit it up with his assistance, pulling it out. He only just managed to return it to the bag and push Cindy off his lap when Kayla entered the living room. She sat on the couch on his left side since Cindy was on his right. She leaned against him and rested her head on his shoulder. Jaden only just realized the TV had been on this whole time. He sighed with relief when he saw Cindy pretending to watch as well. Somehow they had not gotten caught.
—————————————————————————————————————————————————————-
After the show on the TV ended, the 3 of them went to the kitchen to eat. Cindy did a good job of pretending her cunt was not full of plastic eggs, but Jaden could tell she was walking with a limp.
After eating, the 3 of them returned to the couch and put on a DVD Jaden had brought. It was part of their date. While having Cindy leave them alone to cuddle would have been preferable, Kayla did not push too hard. She wanted to appear like a caring older sister, hoping she could win Jaden over that way as well.
Having woken up early to practice cooking, and having spent all afternoon in front of the stove, it was hard on Kayla to stay awake for the movie. Halfway through, she leaned on the far armrest and began to snore softly.
Jaden pretended to try waking her while actually making sure she was deep enough asleep that any noise would not bother her. As soon as he was positive, he reached to his other side and began touching Cindy’s crotch. She had been focused on the movie and not realized Kayla was asleep. She panicked and covered her mouth at first but sighed with relief when she looked past him as saw her sister asleep.
She let him finger her and fondle her breasts for a while before he finally just pulled her up into his lap. She finally felt the warmth of his exposed cock touching her from below. The tip pressed her cunt and made her moan, but it could not fit inside, not while she was stuffed with plastic eggs.
She expected Jaden to try removing them and she even tried helping expel them by clenching her abdomen. However, Jaden instead went back to his bag of items. He produced the blue dildo again and shoved it against her tight cunt, spreading the eggs apart to make room for the hard object. Before supper she might have been able to stand it but having just eaten she was on the verge of puking.
Jaden ignored her clutching her stomach and instead retrieved a small tube of lubrication from his bag. He spread some on the tip of his cock and then the rest in-between her butt cheeks. It took her only a moment to realize what he was planning. She twisted her head as much as she could to look at his face. Her mouth was quivering as she tried not to throw up. Drool was leaking from her lips as her body prepared to protect itself from the potential bile.
With one thrust, Jaden’s lubricated cock slid into Cindy’s puckered asshole, stretching it and making her wheeze. She was winded and did nothing to maintain her balance on his lap, almost trying to fall off. He grabbed her pigtails, causing her to straighten her neck and face forward. With her hair as handles he began to thrust into her butt, pushing her forward off his lap, and then pulling her back onto him.
Cindy could do nothing but cover her mouth to keep from throwing up as her bowels were stretched and filled alongside her pussy. She could not help but realize that if he had his chopstick with him he could have filled a 3rd hole with a 9th object.
“Are you alright?” Jaden had expected her to be more vocal about getting fucked in her ass. Her only response to his question was to shake her head. “Come on, it can’t be that bad. You’ve had worse things shoved in your bladder.” He refused to acknowledge her discomfort.
Eventually Cindy could not keep her stomach from turning. She leaned forward and pulled the dildo out of her cunt just in time to push it into her mouth to block the bile rising in her throat. Jaden recognized the sound and stood up. He rushed to the kitchen to let her puke in the sink but just then he saw Kayla stirring. Rather than the noise, the movement of them leaving the couch had disturbed her.
He quickly ran out the back door, still holding Cindy against his chest. He set her down in a bush and pulled his cock out of her butt. She keeled over and puked the dildo and her dinner out onto the ground. Jaden could not see her face as it had gotten dark out, but he knew she must look like a mess. How they planned to get back inside without Kayla being suspicious was a mystery to him. The only option he could think of was to leave Cindy alone outside so that they could re-enter at different times and hopefully not be too suspicious.
When he entered the house again he saw Kayla in the kitchen putting the leftovers of their meal in Tupperware. “Hey sweetie,” he grabbed her waist from behind.
“Jaden, I think I might have something wrong with my vision.”
“What do you mean?” he gulped nervously.
“Well, I fell asleep on the couch, right? But I wasn’t fully asleep, or at least I don’t think I was. I kept drifting back into consciousness, but I might have just been dreaming, or having a wet dream.” She lowered her hands to his on her waist.
“What did you dream?” he played along.
“I thought I saw Cindy sitting on your lap.”
“She sits on my lap a lot. That’s not an odd thing to dream.”
“She wasn’t just sitting on it. You were doing it… I mean really, she was bent over, almost horizontal to the floor and you were thrusting into her so hard, using her hair like handles. I thought it was real except there was no way she wouldn’t be screaming if you did that to her, right?”
“Are you perhaps telling me you want me to pull your hair when we have sex,” he teased her.
She bit her lip. “I’ve been trying to satisfy your kinks, I really have. The golden shower last month and then you kept poking my peehole last week. I don’t think I like kinky sex as much as you do.”
“That’s okay.”
“Is it okay because you’ve already found someone else to do that with?” she asked. Her tone suggested she already knew the answer.
“Who would that be?” he played coy.
“Where is Cindy?” she asked a different question.
“She went outside to play,” he answered.
“Outside where you just came from?” Kayla walked over to the living room coffee table. Jaden winced when she peered into his paper bag. The only thing left inside was the remote to the eggs. However, when she leaned down to pick it up, she also picked up Cindy’s discarded panties. He winced but said nothing. She pressed the button on the remote, immediately Cindy’s voice emanated from the kitchen window where she had been peeking in.
“Kay, I can explain,” Jaden sputtered.
“You don’t have to.” Kayla rushed to the kitchen to let her sister in through the window. She could hear the eggs vibrating inside her and even feel them through her skin. “Are you okay?” she asked. Cindy nodded and tried to smile. “He didn’t hurt you?”
“It hurts a little,” Cindy was bluntly honest. Kayla sighed with relief. She knew what her sister meant; it hurt like sex, not like abuse.
“Do you like him?” she asked something else.
Cindy was confused. She had been asked this before, when Kayla first brought Jaden over. She wanted to be sure her sister could get along with her boyfriend before they got serious. “If you like him, then I like him,” Cindy answered the same way she had before.
“I’m being serious here. Do you wish he was your boyfriend?”
Cindy looked utterly confused. “Why would I? Isn’t he yours?”
“But you two are fucking behind my back.”
“Is fucking something only couples can do?”
“Well there are fuck buddies that don’t have to date.”
“Then that’s what we are. You two date and then he fucks me afterward.”
Kayla looked shocked. “You like it that way?”
“I don’t know. He likes fucking me and I like making him happy.”
“Kay…” Jaden tried to interject.
“Show me,” Kayla cut him off.
“Excuse me?” he was shocked.
Kayla made sure he knew she was directing her command at Cindy. “Show me how he fucks you. It must be something if you both feel like doing it right beside me.”
Cindy tilted her head in thought. After a moment she opened one of the silverware drawers in the kitchen and pulled out a metal chopstick. She then used the drawer like a stepping stool to get up onto the counter. She sat with her legs spread facing Kayla, shaking with the eggs still vibrating in her. She pressed the tip of the chopstick into her own urethra with some difficulty. Her eyes rolled back and she leaned her head backwards. Kayla fiddled with her fingers at the crotch of her dress as she watched her sister work the stick almost all the way into herself.
“He loves to fuck my peehole,” Cindy explained. “He makes me piss myself and then uses the wetness to shove his penis into me. He calls me a slut and a bad girl while kissing me. I can’t tell if he loves me or hates me but he really likes touching my body.”
Liquid ran along the chopstick to the end and drizzled onto the floor. Eventually her pussy became wet enough for the eggs to start shaking themselves out. Cindy’s tongue stuck out as she felt them touching her clit as they left her body. She rolled her head to look straight at Jaden and pleaded “fuck me,” in a meek voice.
He caught the last egg before it hit the floor and pushed it into her mouth, causing her teeth to chatter until she could push it into her cheek. She made a sound as she sucked her own fluid off of it and swallowed. Kayla watched her boyfriend scoop her little sister up and plant her sopping cunt onto his cock. She shrieked as his waist pushed the chopstick deep into her bladder.
Kayla continued to fiddle with her own crotch through her dress as she watched her poor little sister shrieking like a banshee as a cock that was far too big for her stretched her tiny hole. Kayla had no idea how it even fit. The reason for the chopstick was apparent, it was the only thing Jaden could fit into her, but somehow it got her wet enough to accept his cock after some effort.
“Which do you like more, the stick or his cock?” Kayla asked.
“Cock?” Cindy did not recognize the word. “His penis is softer and it bends slightly, but it is so much bigger. Also, he loves to stick it in my mouth and butt, so it’s annoying.”
“Show me.” Kayla tugged on Jaden’s arm. Cindy shook her head but Jaden was already lifting her off his cock. He slammed his wet member into her tight asshole and slid all the way inside in one move. Cindy turned and threw up on the floor.
Kayla left the room to get a mop. When she came back, Jaden was sitting on the couch, still bouncing Cindy’s asshole on his cock. She was staring at the ceiling, trying not to be sick again.
After she cleaned up the floor, Kayla came to the living room and began to push the chopstick in and out of her sister’s urethra. “Don’t!” Cindy cried.
“But you look so cute getting your holes stretched. I’d call you a slut if I thought you knew what it meant.”
“Yes, I’m a slut. Jaden calls me that all the time. So please, don’t move it in me right now. I can’t hold it.”
“That’s not my problem. You stole my boyfriend. The least you can do is entertain me. I wish I had a cock. We’d double stuff your pussy and butt at the same time, or spit roast you like a pig. I bet your throat feels amazing.” Kayla pushed her fingers into Cindy’s mouth and spread them, poking her cheeks and tongue. Cindy wretched and nearly threw up again.
“Stop,” she pleaded. “I’m sorry you don’t have a penis, but you can fuck me later. You can use a soda bottle or the plastic penis Jaden brought. The shower head actually fits inside me pretty well. We live together so you can fuck me whenever you want after Jaden goes home. Just please let me rest right now.” Saliva frothed at the corners of her mouth as she struggled to speak with his sister’s fingers inside her.
“So this is how you got her to be your slut,” Kayla snickered. “She’s not thinking about the future at all, just making empty promises to get you to stop in the moment.”
Jaden looked concerned. “Is she my slut though?”
“You’re fucking her asshole while she pleads for anything else and you’re asking me?” Kayla scoffed.
“You’re my girlfriend. She’s just your sister. If we break up, I’ll never see her again.”
“That’s true. Mom definitely won’t let you date her. I guess if you want to keep coming over here to rape my sister behind Mom’s back, we better pretend to still be dating.”
“Why would you do that? It’s not like we’d be a real couple. I only want to fuck Cindy anymore. We won’t have sex at all.”
“I don’t need sex from you anymore.” Kayla pulled the chopstick out of Cindy as well as her fingers. The girl only gurgled in response. Jaden watched as she left through the back door. It only took her a moment to return with the blue dildo Cindy had thrown up in the bushes. She washed it in the sink before returning to the living room. She stroked Cindy’s hair as she shook her head in fear. A moment later, the dildo was embedded in her cunt, making her wheeze. “You’re so cute when you’re afraid,” Kayla teased her.
Cindy tried to nod but passed out instead. As Kayla could not feel anything and had just been relying on Cindy’s reactions to get off, she got bored of double penetrating the young girl quite quickly. She let Jaden fuck her for another few minutes until he came inside her asshole.
When he had set her down and put his pants back on properly, Kayla finally spoke to him again. “Where did you get all these?” she pulled the last egg out of Cindy’s sleeping mouth.
“There is a store in the mall that sells emo stuff in the front and adult toys in the back.”
“Kinky, can you bring some more stuff, like a collar and handcuffs.”
“What are you planning to do to your sister?” Jaden was concerned.
“She’s just my pet now,” Kayla laughed. “And you have no room to talk. Don’t worry, when you come over next time I’ll have her fully ready for you.”
“You sound like her pimp.”
“She needs to be punished.” Kayla shrugged.
Jaden was worried about Cindy but it was not like he could take her with him. He also could only rely on Kayla to let them see each other again. He was addicted to her tiny holes now and he would do anything to keep access to her, even letting her sister abuse her.